"Emanuel Kant once decreed that human understanding was such that we necessarily saw the world in terms of cause and effect..." The man on the street still does, but how do today's scientists understand this relation?
Jerome
Jerome
-
Re: The refutation of Emanuel Kant's view of cause and effect in human understanding
Thu, May 4, 2006 - 10:25 AMDepends which scientist you're talking to. I suspect you're making a reference to quantum mechanics? -
-
Re: The refutation of Emanuel Kant's view of cause and effect in human understanding
Fri, May 5, 2006 - 1:11 PMReading Erwin Schrodinger’s “My View of the World” prompted my inquiry about cause and effect. Schrodinger refers to the connection between the material world and our experience as “hypothetical.” Schrodinger goes on to state that the material world, “…is not really observable, not, that is, as a propter hoc but only as a post hoc. The first of these considerations makes the hypothesis of the material world metaphysical, because there is nothing observable that corresponds to it; the second makes it mystical, because it requires the application of an empirically well-founded mutual relation between two objects (cause and effect) to pairs of objects of which only one (the sense-perception or volition) is ever really perceived or observed, while the other (the material cause or material achievement) is merely an imaginative construct.
Perhaps the subject of my post should have been “Erwin Schrodinger’s ‘My View of the World’ and his treatment of ‘cause and effect’” -
-
Re: The refutation of Emanuel Kant's view of cause and effect in human understanding
Fri, May 5, 2006 - 1:14 PMplato.stanford.edu/entries/...lational/
Relational quantum mechanics is an interpretation of quantum theory which discards the notions of absolute state of a system, absolute value of its physical quantities, or absolute event. The theory describes only the way systems affect each other in the course of physical interactions. State and physical quantities refer always to the interaction, or the relation, between two systems. Nevertheless, the theory is assumed to be complete. The physical content of quantum theory is understood as expressing the net of relations connecting all different physical systems.
-
-